Rates Jump Back to 7.50%: FHA or Conventional for First-Time Buyers Right Now?
The average top-tier 30-year fixed rate is 7.50% per Mortgage News Daily, up 0.08 on Friday and up about a third of a point in just three days. That wipes out most of the improvement rates made since early October and puts the average close to the 7.61% 52-week high. If you are buying your first home, a jump like this usually brings one question to the top of the list: should I go FHA or conventional? Here is how to compare them, with the payment math on a $400,000 home.
What happened this week
Mortgage News Daily reported that the 30-year average rose 0.32 over three days to 7.50%, giving back almost all of October's gains. Bonds lost ground late Thursday, too late for most lenders to reprice that day, so the move showed up in Friday morning rate sheets. The 10-year Treasury yield is still above 5 percent. Keep in mind the Freddie Mac survey of 7.11% was collected earlier in the week, before most of this jump, which is why the two numbers look so far apart right now. I do not predict where rates go from here. My own posted 30-year conventional rate is 7.125% for well-qualified borrowers, and the details are on my live rates page.
Why FHA is pricing below conventional
Look at the callout above: the average FHA rate is 7.05%, almost half a point under the conventional average. That gap is normal, because FHA loans carry a government guarantee, but it gets more attention when conventional rates climb. The lower rate is not the whole story, though. FHA charges an upfront mortgage insurance premium of 1.75% of the loan, usually added to the balance, plus an annual premium that is 0.55% for most borrowers putting less than 5% down. With less than 10% down, that annual premium stays for the life of the loan unless you refinance out of it. Conventional loans with less than 20% down carry private mortgage insurance (PMI) instead, which is priced on your credit score and can be removed once you reach enough equity.
The payment math on a $400,000 home
Here is a side by side using the Mortgage News Daily averages. Your own rate will differ, but the comparison method is the same.
Conventional with 5% down
- Down payment: $20,000, so the loan is $380,000.
- Principal and interest at 7.50%: about $2,657 a month, before PMI.
FHA with 3.5% down
- Down payment: $14,000, so the base loan is $386,000, or $392,755 with the 1.75% upfront premium financed.
- Principal and interest at 7.05%: about $2,626 a month.
- Annual mortgage insurance at 0.55%: about $177 a month, for a total of about $2,803.
So the FHA payment is about $146 a month higher than the conventional payment before PMI. That number is your decision line. If your conventional PMI quote comes in under about $146 a month, conventional likely wins on payment, and the PMI can come off later. If PMI comes in higher, which is common with mid-range credit scores, FHA likely wins on payment and also needs $6,000 less down. For perspective, the three-day jump alone added about $83 a month to that $380,000 conventional loan compared with Tuesday's 7.18% average.
Want FHA and conventional quoted side by side?
Send me your price range, down payment, and rough credit score. I will price both, including the real PMI quote, so you can see which one costs less for you. No credit pull to start.
Other things first-time buyers should weigh
Credit score matters more for conventional than FHA, so a buyer with a 640 score and a buyer with a 780 score can land on opposite answers for the same house. FHA allows somewhat higher debt-to-income ratios, which can help if student loans or a car payment are tight. Condos need FHA approval for an FHA loan, and you can look a project up with my FHA/VA condo checker. If you are a veteran or active duty, compare VA too, since the average VA rate is 7.07% with no monthly mortgage insurance. And if rates are making you nervous about timing, my earlier post on lock strategy walks through how to think about locking once you are under contract, and the buydown and points post shows ways to bring the payment down.
The bottom line
The 30-year fixed is back to 7.50% per Mortgage News Daily after a three-day climb of about a third of a point, while the average FHA rate sits at 7.05%. On a $400,000 home, FHA with 3.5% down runs about $2,803 a month including mortgage insurance, versus about $2,657 plus PMI for conventional with 5% down. The deciding number is your PMI quote: under about $146 a month favors conventional, over it favors FHA. I cannot tell you where rates go next, so get both options priced on your own credit and pick the one that works at today's rate.